Court dismisses Maria Chin’s travel ban appeal

Source: FreeMalaysiaToday

Maria Chin Abdullah failed in her bid to challenge the Immigration director-general’s decision to bar her from travelling abroad after her judicial review application was dismissed. ― Picture by Yusof Mat Isa for the MMO.

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal has dismissed former Bersih 2.0 chairperson Maria Chin Abdullah’s appeal after she was stopped from leaving Malaysia in 2016.

A three-member bench chaired by Justice Umi Kalthum Abdul Majid said the matter was academic and the court would not want to act in vain.

“We are of the view the appeal has become academic and there is no travesty of justice,” she said.

Maria, who was recently elected Petaling Jaya MP, can now travel abroad as the ban has been lifted.

On May 18 last year, the High Court in Kuala Lumpur ruled that an amendment to the Immigration Act did not allow the courts to hear complaints from citizens who are banned from travelling overseas. Read more

Court of Appeal hearing for Maria Chin’s travel ban

Source: FreeMalaysiaToday

Maria Chin Abdullah failed in her bid to challenge the Immigration director-general’s decision to bar her from travelling abroad after her judicial review application was dismissed. ― Picture by Yusof Mat Isa for the MMO.

PUTRAJAYA: The Court of Appeal has dismissed former Bersih 2.0 chairperson Maria Chin Abdullah’s appeal after she was stopped from leaving Malaysia in 2016.

A three-member bench chaired by Justice Umi Kalthum Abdul Majid said the matter was academic and the court would not want to act in vain.

“We are of the view the appeal has become academic and there is no travesty of justice,” she said.

Maria, who was recently elected Petaling Jaya MP, can now travel abroad as the ban has been lifted.

On May 18 last year, the High Court in Kuala Lumpur ruled that an amendment to the Immigration Act did not allow the courts to hear complaints from citizens who are banned from travelling overseas.

Justice Nik Hasmat Nik Mohamad said, as such, she could not provide the remedy sought by Maria.

“The ouster clause in Section 59A of the Immigration Act has prevented aggrieved citizens the right to judicial review,” the judge said in dismissing the suit brought by Maria.

She said Section 59 of the legislation further allowed the respondents – the home minister and the Immigration Department director-general – the right not to give reasons why such a ban was being imposed, except for procedural non-compliance.

Maria had claimed that she was informed of her travel ban just shortly before she was to board a flight to South Korea on May 15 , 2016, at the Kuala Lumpur International Airport.

Maria had applied to quash the decision made by the respondents to blacklist her from travelling abroad. She had also sought a declaration that the respondents did not have the power to reach the decision and had, therefore, acted in excess of their jurisdiction.

Lawyer Gurdial Singh Nijar, who represented Maria, today submitted that the court should make a ruling to determine the power of the (Immigration Department) director-general.

He said a ruling for future guidance was needed or else the authorities could be irrational and unreasonable in imposing travel bans.

“Where else could we go for remedy if not to the court to act as final arbiter ?” he asked.

Gurdial said failure of the court to make a ruling would put a stamp of approval to the decision of the director-general.

“The issue at hand is not about a private right of a citizen but a matter of public interest,” he said.

Government lawyer Shamsul Bolhassan submitted that there were case laws to support the fact that the court need not hear an academic issue and deliver decision.

“It will be hypothetical to decide on the powers of the director-general,” he said.

Speaking to reporters, Gurdial said the court had abdicated its duty by refusing to entertain the appeal.

“By abstaining, the court has given an unfettered discretion to the director-general to decide on the right to travel,” he said.

Gurdial said it was acceptable if a person was stopped from leaving Malaysia due to a criminal charge or while criminal investigations were conducted.

Maria said she filed the action in court as she had been prevented from leaving the country to accept a human rights award on behalf of Bersih.

“Later we found out the grounds to impose the prohibition was that I will be tarnishing the image of the country,” she said.

 

Related Article

 

Tony Pua’s travel ban challenge fizzles out

Source: FMT News

Tony Pua-Pic drawn from FMT News

PUTRAJAYA: Petaling Jaya Utara MP Tony Pua’s challenge against the decision of the Immigration Department director-general to impose a travel ban has come to an end.

This follows today’s Federal Court ruling that dismissed his application for leave to appeal.

“The law is settled in Loh Wai Kong’s case, as decided by (the then Lord President) Mohamed Suffian Mohamed Hashim,” said Chief Justice Raus Sharif, who chaired a three-man panel.

Loh had sought a ruling that Malaysian citizens are entitled to travel overseas as a fundamental right under Article 5 of the Federal Constitution.

However, the Federal Court bench, led by Suffian, held in 1979 that the right to personal liberty under Article 5 was only to challenge the authorities for any unlawful detention. Read more

UN wants govt to drop sedition charges against Zunar

Source: FMT News

The United Nations (UN) wants Putrajaya to drop all sedition charges against Zunar and to lift the travel ban imposed on the political cartoonist last year. Image taken from FMT News.

PETALING JAYA: The United Nations (UN) wants the Malaysian government to drop all sedition charges against political cartoonist Zulkiflee Anwar Ulhaque and lift the travel ban which was imposed on him last June.

UN Special Rapporteur in the field of cultural rights Karima Bennoune, who was in Malaysia at Putrajaya’s invitation from Sept 11 to 21, expressed “deep concern” about the charges against Zulkiflee, better known as Zunar.

A report on her preliminary observations following her visit said Bennoune and other UN human rights experts would be following developments closely when Zunar’s trial resumes next week. Read more

Ambiga fails in bid to challenge her ban to enter Sabah

Source: FMT News

PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court today dismissed an application by former Malaysian Bar president Ambiga Sreenevasan to challenge her ban to enter Sabah, ruling the state authorities of Sabah and Sarawak have absolute power over immigration.

“The decision in the case of Sugumar Balakrishnan v Pihak Berkuasa Negeri Sabah in 2002 is still good law,” said Chief Judge of Malaya Ahmad Maarop who chaired a 3-man bench.

The other judges were Justices Abu Samah Nordin and Azahar Mohamed.

Ambiga was refused entry into Sabah in 2014.

Lawyer Gurdial Singh Nijar, who appeared for Ambiga, told reporters the court’s decision affirmed that both states had absolute and unfettered discretion to determine who could enter their territories. Read more

For Malaysian mum trapped in China, son trumps freedom

Source: The Malay Mail Online 

KUALA LUMPUR, Aug 4 — A Malaysian mother barred from leaving China due to her efforts to recover her twice-abducted child said she does not regret her actions.

Instead, she spoke of her determination to fight the ban and regain their freedom to leave China and return home.

Cheng Chau Yang, 42, told Malay Mail Online of the events stretching back years that led to the ongoing travel ban against her and her eight-year-old Malaysian child, and her continued struggle to keep her child with her.

Cheng married a Chinese national in 2004 and had a son in July 2009, but the marriage was described by Women’s Aid Organisation (WAO) and her family’s lawyer as “abusive”, with Cheng suffering both verbal and physical abuse. Read more

Why fear cartoonists if you have done no wrong, asks Zunar

Source: The Malaysian Insight

Cartoonist Zunar was forced to cancel his first street exhibition entitled ‘Ketawa Pink Pink’ in Penang after threats from a group of troublemakers. – The Malaysian Insight file pic, July 31, 2017.

IF as Putrajaya claims that the US Department of Justice suits related to 1MDB are politically motivated, then it should not be so zealous in its pursuit of critics here, said cartoonist Zulkiflee Anwar Ulhaque.

On Saturday, the cartoonist better known as Zunar was forced to cancel his first street exhibition entitled “Ketawa Pink Pink” that was to open at Lebuh Pantai, Penang, the next day because of “threats from a group of troublemakers”.

The exhibition was to feature his drawings of a well-known woman with pink diamond jewellery.

In the latest DoJ suit filed last month, it noted that nearly US$30 million (RM129 million) were allegedly stolen from 1Malaysia Development Bhd to buy jewellery, including a 22-carat rare pink diamond set in a necklace worth a US$27.3 million for the wife of “Malaysian Official No. 1” (MO1) in 2013. Read more

Heng: We’re confident China’s laws can handle M’sian mother-and-son case

Source: The Star Online

KUALA LUMPUR: The case of a Malaysian in China who, along with her son, has been banned from leaving the Middle Kingdom since October 2015, will be handled according to local laws, says the Chinese embassy here.

“China practises the rule of law and everyone is equal before the law,” an embassy spokesman said when contacted yesterday.

Cheng Chau Yang’s plight was highlighted by Wanita MCA chief Datuk Heng Seai Kie at a press conference at Wisma MCA on Friday.

Both Cheng, 42, and her eight-year-old son, who live in Shanghai, are prohibited from leaving China following a Shanghai court order on the travel ban after a request by Cheng’s ex-husband, a Chinese national.

The ban is renewable every three months until the son turns 18. Read more

Groups urge China to lift travel ban on two Malaysians, stop rights violation

Source: The Malay Mail Online

KUALA LUMPUR, July 28 — China should remove a travel ban on two Malaysians there instead of denying their rights to freely enter and exit the country, local advocacy groups said today.

Voice of the Children’s chairman Sharmila Sekaran noted that China is a signatory to the United Nations’ Convention on the Rights of the Child (UNCRC), highlighting the international human rights treaty’s Articles 3 and 10 which requires a child’s “best interests” to be considered and to be allowed free movement between countries to meet their family members abroad.

Commenting on the plight of Cheng Chau Yang and her eight-year-old son who are barred by Chinese authorities from leaving China, Sharmila pointed out that the UNCRC also touches on governments’ obligations to respect a child’s right to an identity in forms such as nationality, culture and family ties.

“This child first and foremost is a Malaysian national who has been denied the right to come back to Malaysia to absorb his Malaysian-ness, and discover himself as a Malaysian… He is denied the right to eat Malaysian food and more importantly he is denied his right to his Malaysian family,” she said at a joint press conference with other advocacy groups and Cheng’s family. Read more

Tony Pua’s appeal to challenge 2015 travel ban fails

Source: The StarOnline

Pic taken from The Star Online

PUTRAJAYA: Petaling Jaya Utara MP Tony Pua failed in his bid to challenge the Immigration Department director-general’s decision to bar him from travelling abroad.

Pua had filed an appeal against the High Court’s July 2016 dismissal of his judicial review application challenging the director-general’s decision.

He named the director-general and the Government as respondents.

In a unanimous decision Wednesday, Court of Appeal judge Justice Mohd Zawawi Salleh said there was no reason for the panel to interfere with the High Court’s decision. Read more